Survivalist Pro
Photo by Sven Huls Pexels Logo Photo: Sven Huls

Should you drink sea water if stranded?

Current documents such as the US Army Survival Manual FM 3-05.70 (FM 21-76) clearly advise not to drink seawater or urine in the event of a shipwreck. However, it does validate other ideas put into practice by Bombard, such as reducing food to the essential, since digestion consumes water from the body.

What is a T3 student?
What is a T3 student?

High School Level T3 Overview The High School Level T3 (or Tier 3) Program is a Special Education program for students with an Individualized...

Read More »
How do I keep my static caravan warm in the winter?
How do I keep my static caravan warm in the winter?

Short term tips to keep your caravan warm in winter Put up thermal curtains. ... Don't block your radiators. ... Add thicker rugs. ... Buy a...

Read More »

On October 19, 1952, the French physician and biologist Alain Bombard went to sea alone in Las Palmas de Gran Canaria aboard an inflatable Zodiac boat, with a sextant and hardly any provisions. With so few means, his objective seemed completely unreasonable—to cross the Atlantic Ocean. But he succeeded—65 days later, on December 23, he reached land in Barbados, having lost 25 kilos, but alive, and without suffering from serious health consequences; he would die in 2005 at the respectable age of 80. Five years earlier, in 1947, Norwegian adventurer Thor Heyerdahl had led the Kon-Tiki expedition across the Pacific to prove that ancient peoples might have expanded across the ocean with primitive resources. But unlike Heyerdahl, Bombard’s interest was not the thirst for adventure, but simply thirst, in its most literal and biological sense. The Kon-Tiki voyage had proved that ancient navigators were able to survive in the ocean by hydrating themselves with fish juice and drinking seawater mixed with fresh water in a ratio of 2:3. Bombard had known of the deaths of several shipwrecked sailors while working as a doctor in Boulogne-sur-Mer, but he was convinced that it was not dehydration that killed them, but rather despair. Thus it was proposed to demonstrate that it was possible to survive a shipwreck only with the resources available on the high seas, including salt water. After an intense period of study at the Monaco Oceanographic Institute and some prior preparatory runs in the Mediterranean and Africa, Bombard had just enough time to return to Paris for the birth of his first daughter, before facing the trip where he would risk his own life to prove his theory. The regime designed by Bombard consisted of feeding himself minimally with plankton—rich in vitamins—and raw fish. The most critical need, hydration, would be solved by squeezing the fluid from the fish and collecting rainwater, supplemented with small doses of seawater that did not exceed one litre a day—one tablespoon at intervals of 20 minutes, allowing the saliva to dilute the salt in the mouth.

The Mad Doctor

Does putting a frozen bottle of water in front of a fan work?
Does putting a frozen bottle of water in front of a fan work?

All you have to do is freeze an empty 4 pint or 1 litre plastic bottle, place it on a tray and cover with a damp cloth. Position this in front of...

Read More »
What is the best survival manual?
What is the best survival manual?

(#1-7) Best Survival Books for the Wilderness SAS Survival Guide | John “Lofty” Wiseman. ... The Ultimate Survival Manual | Rich Johnson. ... How...

Read More »

The latter was the most controversial aspect of the experiment, something Bombard was aware of when he named his boat L’Hérétique, the heretic. In his own country he was branded Docteur Fou, the Mad Doctor. His contemporary, the German physician Hannes Lindemann, also a solitary navigator, questioned the veracity of the saltwater ingestion experiment as Bombard described it in his book Naufragé volontaire (Éditions de Paris, 1953). The Frenchman had a sealed emergency kit with provisions and water, but he was not supposed to use it; only a few days before his arrival in Barbados he was aided by a ship, where they offered him lunch. It has long been known that humans cannot keep themselves hydrated with salt water. Those who do die dehydrated after suffering a poisoning that makes them lose their mind. “Human kidneys can only make urine that is less salty than salt water,” explains the US Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). Specifically, the urine reaches a maximum level of about 2% salt, while seawater is around 3.5%. When we drink salt water, the salinity of our blood increases and the excess must be expelled. “To get rid of all the excess salt taken in by drinking seawater, you have to urinate more water than you drank,” continues NOAA. Specifically, to lower the salt from one litre of seawater to 2%, the kidney needs to add 0.75 litres of body water. “Eventually, you die of dehydration even as you become thirstier.” When the body cannot remove excess sodium, there is an imbalance whose effects on the organs, including the nervous system, trigger the symptoms that lead to coma and death.

Small amounts of seawater

In the Second World War, shipwrecks were plentiful and there were stories of sailors who had survived by drinking small amounts of seawater. In 1943, the UK National Hospital physician W. S. S. Laddell published a study in The Lancet in which he tested this possibility. Laddell found that “a man in water debt continues to produce 350-450 cc of urine a day.” But in his experiments supplementing freshwater intake with salt water, Laddell found that “there was a slight gain to the body of water, because the extra water lost in the urine is less than the extra water ingested as seawater.” Although Laddell himself added a note warning that the committee that had commissioned the study to assist shipwreck survivors in combat did not recommend drinking seawater, the truth is that Bombard’s thesis has not been definitively refuted. In 1987, a study with rats concluded that “when a man is stranded at sea, it is not advisable to drink all the fresh water and then to be compelled to drink seawater when dehydrated.” Instead, researchers at Israel’s Ben-Gurion University recommend, “slowly increasing the seawater uptake” when the survivor is still well hydrated.

Did Battlefield 2042 sell well?
Did Battlefield 2042 sell well?

The game's launch was a bit of a mess, with basic features missing, performance issues, and more. As a result, EA claims that Battlefield 2042...

Read More »
Do Navy SEALs use Tomahawks?
Do Navy SEALs use Tomahawks?

SEAL Team 6 reportedly uses tomahawks created by renowned North Carolina knife maker Daniel Winkler. Winkler also created the tomahawks used in the...

Read More »

Current documents such as the US Army Survival Manual FM 3-05.70 (FM 21-76) clearly advise not to drink seawater or urine in the event of a shipwreck. However, it does validate other ideas put into practice by Bombard, such as reducing food to the essential, since digestion consumes water from the body. Also one should take advantage of the juice of the fish, specifically the fluid of the eye and that surrounding the spine, as these liquids are less saline than seawater. To reduce sweating, it is advisable to protect oneself from the sun and to moisten and wring out one’s clothing. Although today there is no shortage of desalination or water evaporation system, Bombard’s legacy continues to assist castaways, at least in one independent aspect of the eternal debate on saltwater intake. According to what the French seafarer Gérard d’Aboville wrote in Bombard’s obituary published in the Libération newspaper on July 20, 2005, the Mad Doctor “understood that it is first and foremost hope that allows a survivor to survive, and he demonstrated it.”

Javier Yanes

@yanes68

What is the oldest book in existence?
What is the oldest book in existence?

The Diamond Sutra Do you, however, know which the oldest dated printed book still in existence even today is? That honour goes to The Diamond Sutra...

Read More »
What vitamin deficiency causes you to feel cold?
What vitamin deficiency causes you to feel cold?

Lack of vitamin B12 and iron deficiency can cause anemia and lead you to feel cold.

Read More »
How much weight can you lose on 7-day juice cleanse?
How much weight can you lose on 7-day juice cleanse?

1-2lbs Yes, research shows that people can lose 1-2lbs of weight per day on a juice cleanse. Ultimately, this figure is influenced by your starting...

Read More »
Did Rules of Survival died?
Did Rules of Survival died?

The game was later taken down from Steam by June 13, 2018, and reinstated by June 28, 2018. As of June 27, 2022, ROS ceased its operations, and...

Read More »